Friday, April 25, 2008

UMA+LTE: It's all good

Recently there has been a flurry of activity around the next generation Radio Access Network (RAN) technology known at LTE. LTE is the ‘all IP’ access network for mobile service providers. With very high throughput (>100mbps) and very low latency (targeting 5msec), LTE is designed to a be a true wireless broadband access network.

With that in mind, people have started questioning UMA’s role in an LTE environment. While there are a lot issues still in flux (including LTE itself), and much work still to be done, what is clear is that the core drivers behind UMA in a 2G or 3G environment still apply in LTE.

Some people simplistically view UMA as redundant in an LTE environment because they both ‘deliver services over an IP access network.’ This view completely misses the value of UMA in a Home Zone 2.0 (femtocell or dual-mode handset) service deployment.

Operator deploying Home Zone 2.0 services in a 2G or 3G network are doing so for three reasons:

  • Create service zone unique from the macro network with the goal of offering differentiated services/billing based on location.
  • Offload the macro RAN, especially for very high speed, media rich audio and video application.
  • Improve the performance, coverage and throughput rate for mobile data services when indoors/in the home zone.

These same service drivers apply directly, and in some cases are even more relevant, to an LTE RAN:

  • Create a unique service zone (still a competitive advantage)
  • Offload the macro RAN (definitely for the projected data rates)
  • Improve coverage/performance (certainly if LTE is at 2 gHz or higher)

As the market evolves, UMA will continue to evolve as well. Just as UMA started as a 2G technology and evolved to support the 3G/Iu interfaces, UMA will continue to evolve into key solution in an LTE-enabled network.

Thursday, April 24, 2008

Cisco to buy ip.Access? Better to wait...

The industry is buzzing today with the rumor that ip.Access has ‘won’ a contract with AT&T to supply femtocells. The reportedly $500,000,000 contract for 7,000,000 units gives you an ASP of $71.43/unit. Ouch.

What exactly did they win? The right to sell femtocells below cost to AT&T?

Frankly I think it's AT&T that is hoping Cisco buys ip.Access. At least Cisco can afford to lose money on every unit and ‘make it up in volume.’

The article notes that the contract calls for ip.Access to ‘eventually price the units at less than $100 apiece’. If half of the units are sold at $100 each, the other 50% need to be sold at $42.86 to get to an ASP of $71.43. Hummm… that’s probably why the article dryly notes the contract ‘could exceed $500m.’

My advice to Cisco: wait… buy ip.Access out of bankruptcy.

The best way to get costs down in the market: Open standards.

Wednesday, April 23, 2008

Is NSN looking to leave its femto 'partners' behind?

An article from DigiTimes today confirms that Nokia Siemens Networks is in talks with several Taiwan-based manufacturers over plans for joint production of femtocells.

NSN has already signed agreements with Ubiquisys, RadioFrame, Thomson and Airvana for femtocell access points. Yet the article quotes NSN general manager for Taiwan, Hong Kong and Macau Mike Wang, who confirms the company is now in talks with ‘other network equipment makers, including Gemtek Technology and Accton Technology.’

Why would NSN need to source their own femtocells? They have signed up four independent femtocell access point vendors. Why sign up Gemtek and Accton too?

Maybe NSN is getting ready to leave its partners behind.

[UPDATE: In feedback from this blog post, I received word that NSN is rumored to be courting femtocell silicon vendors directly, lending credibility to the idea that they are looking to develop their own femtocell.]



Tuesday, April 22, 2008

UMA: The reason behind the Orange/FT - TeliaSonera discussions

Early last week rumors began circulating that Orange/France Telecom may be interested in acquiring TeliaSonera. An article in the International Herald Tribune provided an analysis, but left an odd question unanswered at the end of the article:

“Why would France Telecom possibly want to make [another] European acquisition?”

As the article points out, there’s little geographic overlap, the logic for incumbents merging is ‘muddled’, and its outside France Telecom’s stated goals.

Finally on Friday, things began to clear up. France Telecom Finance Director Gervais Pellissier said that acquiring TeliaSonera could give FT the scale it needs to counter future competitive threats from companies such as Google and/or Apple.

“How do you expect us to develop the LiveBox if we don’t have several million customers using it? How can we push UMA if we don’t have that power?” asked Mr. Pellissier.

Great question! Pushing UMA is a TOP priority for Orange/FT right now and clearly it’s viewed as a technical competitive advantage. UMA gives Orange an advantage in its “Home Zone 2.0” strategy.

Thursday, April 17, 2008

Dreaming of dual-mode and UMA

It's good to know I'm not alone in the world. There are other technology geeks who dream about cool new stuff.

Check out the post: http://livebolt.com/blog/2008/04/17/visions-of-uma-danced-in-their-heads/

I have similar dreams about UMA and dual-mode services. In my case, I actually use the HotSpot @Home service. I agree that not everyone has signed up with T-Mobile... yet.

Wednesday, April 16, 2008

A Good Week For Handsets (and it's only Wednesday!)

T-Mobile is starting to make good on their promise to bring 10 new HotSpot @Home handsets to market in 2008. Heck, two hit the rumor mill this week alone!

First is the new Samsung T339, a feature-rich mid-tier handset which continues to push Samsung into the upper echelons of DMH supplier.

Second, a rumor broke on HTC’s Shadow II (shown), the appropriately named follow-on to the Shadow currently available from T-Mobile. This is notable for being the first Windows Mobile device with UMA available from T-Mobile.

All this happens in the same week that the UMA-enabled Blackberry Pearl shows up on the shelves of T-Mobile stores nationwide.

T-Mobile is definitely on a roll.

I-WLAN: RIP?

It came to my attention just recently that a key proponent of the 3GPP Interworked Wireless LAN (I-WLAN) specification has passed.

I-WLAN is a 3GPP specification designed to enable ‘nomadic’ devices (e.g. laptops) to access services in the mobile core network over a Wi-Fi/IP connection.

I-WLAN provides a secure connection and authentication mechanism which is similar to UMA. The fundamental difference between I-WLAN and UMA is that I-WLAN lacks mobility for sessions whereas UMA provides seamless mobility for circuit and packet services between IP (Wi-Fi) and GSM networks.

Azaire Networks (www.azairenet.com) disappeared at the end of March, just before the CTIA show. While the I-WLAN specification will live on in the 3GPP, it is likely to become one of the hundreds (?) of specifications which are developed but never achieve any commercial success in the public network.

It’s not enough to have a good idea, technology needs to solve a fundamental business problem. UMA lets mobile operators extend their voice and data services over the low cost, high performance IP access network, and create Home Zone 2.0 services. UMA’s continued success is a direct correlation to demand from service providers.

Internet Offload and UMA

“Internet Offload” is the ability for a dual-mode phone to connect directly to the internet through the Wi-Fi radio. The phone which comes to most people’s mind is the iPhone, but Wi-Fi enabled HTC and Nokia E/N series support this feature too.

When the iPhone enters a Wi-Fi environment, the GSM radio stays on (for circuit voice and mobile packet data services), and the Wi-Fi radio can be used for accessing internet services like Google Maps directly.

For some reason, the market seems to think that a dual-mode phone can support either UMA or Internet Offload, but not both simultaneously.

This is not true!

Internet Offload and UMA are fully compatible functions of a dual-mode phone.

In fact the strongest example is the family of UMA-enabled Blackberries (8820, Curve/8320, Pearl/8120) which all support UMA and Internet Offload concurrently.

Here’s how it works:

When a UMA-enabled Blackberry enters Wi-Fi, the UMA tunnel is established. The UMA tunnel is used to transport services which reside in the mobile core network to the phone. The easiest example is voice services. But any data application which is delivered from the mobile core is accessed through the UMA tunnel, applications like MMS or any stream media services offered from the network (MobiTV,…)

A key advantage of using the UMA tunnel for service delivery is mobility. Any application or service which takes advantage of the UMA tunnel maintains session continuity between the Wi-Fi network and the outdoor macro network.

But it’s the way UMA-enabled Blackberries also support Internet Offload which is most interesting. When the phone tries to access web based services like Google Maps, the traffic is routed directly to the Wi-Fi access layer and out to the internet. No going through the UMA tunnel, no burdening the mobile core with non-revenue generating internet traffic. Note this is also how the Blackberry accesses mail services when in Wi-Fi, directly over the internet.

The trick is that the Blackberry maintains a basic router function in the handset. For application which are ‘hosted’ (circuit voice, SMS, MMS,…), the traffic is routed through the UMA tunnel and to the mobile core. For browser based applications, the traffic is routed directly to the internet.

Note there is no 'seamless mobility' for services routed via Internet Offload directly over Wi-Fi. When the phone moves outside of Wi-Fi coverage, the session ends. The session can be restarted over the macro RAN, but there will be a drop in service.

Why is Internet Offload + UMA important?

First, it’s important to clear up the misunderstanding in the industry. Early UMA phones didn’t support the Internet Offload feature because operators specified they wanted UMA-enabled dual-mode phones to work ‘exactly the same’ in Wi-Fi as in GSM. Therefore, all the packet traffic was to be routed via the UMA tunnel to the mobile core when on Wi-Fi, because all packet traffic is routed to the mobile core when on GSM. [It’s in this way that UMA is really a RAN technology, making Wi-Fi an access radio for mobile services.]

With dual-mode phones supporting Internet Offload on the market, operators are again saying they want UMA-enabled phones to operate ‘exactly the same’. But now this means adding support for Internet Offload concurrently with UMA by routing some traffic over the UMA tunnel and other traffic directly to the internet.

Second, support of Internet Offload is a critical component of making the mobile phone an integral member of the ‘connected home.’ There is a movement underway to bring household electronics together into a cohesive fabric. But a mobile phone without Internet Offload capabilities* will be excluded from supporting local connections in the home. Thus the phone will continue to be outside the ‘connected home’ vision.

By highlighting UMA and Internet Offload support concurrently in the same device, UMA devices can now easily fit into the vision of the ‘connected home’.

Now Nokia N series handsets can support UMA along with the existing Internet Offload capabilities. In fact, the Nokia N95 was one of the first handsets to demonstrate support for DLNA, a ‘connected home’ protocol standard.

[* - There are two ways to make the handset a member of the 'connected home'. First is to have a dual-mode Wi-Fi enabled handset with Internet Offload capabilities. The second, pioneered by the Femto Forum, is to proxy a standard 3G handset into the connected home network via a femtocell.]

Wednesday, April 09, 2008

Still on track for 5.5 million

My favorite pessimistic telecom commentator, Dean Bubley, has recently recapped his outlook on network evolution in his 500th blog post.

Given his general skepticism regarding UMA as a viable technology for dual-mode handset services, I suppose I’m honored that UMA was listed as the very first item he chose to list as ‘over-hyped’.

[Side note: considering UMAToday is the only site ‘hyping’ UMA, I hardly consider it ‘over’-hyped, certainly when compared with other things on the list like WiMAX. But I’ll take that as a compliment that we’re doing something right, thanks Dean.]

But given the comments, I think Dean's jumping the gun a bit:

UMA (unlicenced mobile access) - well, it still hasn't got much traction after another 30 months. Maybe 1.5m subscribers at Orange & T-Mobile US, plus some hopefulness around femtocells. My original forecasts (considered horribly pessimistic at the time) of 5.5m UMA homes at end-2009 now actually look insufficiently pessimistic after all.

First, the comment ‘after another 30 months’ seems a bit odd. Orange only launched 18 months ago (October 2006), and T-mobile just 9 months ago (June 2007). True, we’ve been talking about dual-mode services and UMA for some time, but there hasn’t even been one 30 month period, let alone ‘another’.

But second, I think the forecast Dean made relating to UMA-based dual-mode handsets might actually be one he gets right*. I happen to believe 5m units is within range for 2008. At the end of his prediction period (YE 09), I suspect there will be well over 10m units sold, easily meeting his prediction of 5.5m homes by YE 09.

Thanks for the vote of confidence Dean!


[* Dean is a big fan of the ‘naked SIP’ handset revolution, suggesting that this is the way, rather than UMA, that the market will embrace dual-mode services and VoIP.

In this model, subscribers buy/acquire a Nokia E or N series phone and download a third party SIP client onto the handset. The idea is to bypass those nasty mobile operators and make calls for ‘free’. It's the TruPhone model. Of course, there are several reasons why this won’t work:

  1. Spending $500 on a handset to make cheap calls doesn’t compute. Anyone shelling out $500 for a phone isn’t so concerned about saving pennies on phone calls that they’ll download a second client onto a phone.
  2. Putting a second client and a second phone number (the SIP service) on a handset is a hassle. Consumers and prosumers want a single number that’s available all the time, not just when the handset is connected to Wi-Fi.
  3. Oh, you want to run this SIP client over the 3G network as well as Wi-Fi? Round trip latencies for today’s 3G access network are 200 msec, and that’s just ‘your side’ of the call. It does not take into account the rest of distance those packets must travel. That’s an unacceptable delay for voice calls, even free.

For some reason, Dean’s prediction of 220m ‘naked SIP’ phones shipped in 2008 wasn’t captured in his list of ‘over-hyped’ technologies. I don’t honestly know how many ‘naked SIP’ phones shipped, let alone how many are actually use the application he describes. But I'm willing to guess it's a lot less than 22o million.]

Is 3x Enough?

There is still some misunderstanding on the benefits of dual-mode handsets and home zone services. Operators are struggling to find services which offer some type of benefit, either increasing ARPU or reducing churn. I’m not sure what the market expects, but I think a service that reduces churn by 3x is not bad.

According to a slide deck used in France Telecom’s Investor Days (December, 2007):

“Homes equipped with UNIK churn 3 times less on their mobile contract than others” [slide 20, file: 5-France.pdf]

Is there any other service that reduces churn by 3x? Note this claim is from the actual operator who is realizing the benefit. It is unfiltered, unbiased, and objective information.

Maybe just keeping subscribers on your network isn’t enough...

How about a service that causes new subscribers to churn to your network? In today’s hyper-competitive market, subscriber numbers are a zero sum game, for you to win, someone needs to be losing.

T-Mobile recently announced that nearly 50% of the users taking their HotSpot @Home service are new to the operator.

Frankly that’s a staggering statistic. People are churning to T-Mobile to get a dual-mode handset service. To put it into perspective, an early article on AT&T about the iPhone said that “roughly 40% of iPhone subscribers were new AT&T customers.”

So DMH out-churns the iPhone!?!?! Crazy.

I know iPhone and HotSpot@Home are different, but both are bringing new subscribers to the operator’s network. I haven’t seen churn numbers on the iPhone, presumably because the users are still locked into their 2 year contracts, but 3x reduction on DMH services isn’t bad.

I guess the point of this post is: If you don’t have a UMA-based dual-mode handset service to sell, maybe the iPhone is the next best thing?

Tuesday, March 25, 2008

T-Mo gets the 8820... Finally


The Blackberry 8820, announced about 6 mos ago for AT&T, has finally been released for T-Mobile's HotSpot @Home service. All we can say is: FINALLY!

And in the category of 'what have you done for me lately', we ask "When do we get the UMA-enabled Pearl?"

Monday, March 24, 2008

Qualcomm Positions Wi-Fi and Femtocells

I recently uncovered a very interesting whitepaper on the Qualcomm site. Published in December, 2007 and titled “Femtocells and WLAN Complement 3G and Beyond”, the whitepaper approached the current Wi-Fi/Femto furor with an outlook similar to my own: the imperative is for in-building radios to provide service zones, and is less about which radio technology is used.

By using Wi-Fi or femtocells, operators have the ability to develop a ‘service zone’ where new, differentiated services can be delivered to subscribers.

The paper goes on to outline four reasons why an operator needs to use a technology like Wi-Fi and/or femtocell to complement a 3G deployment:

  • Indoor coverage – which can mean regular ‘coverage’, but now implies improving the data rate/throughput for packet services
  • Capacity gains – good old macro radio offload
  • Cost savings – specifically attributed to the use of broadband/IP for backhaul
  • New Services – specifically Home Zone services, or applications specific to a location.

These are all things that are common to the “Home Zone 2.0” strategy.

My only disagreement in the piece is the discussion about VCC. But this was written before the announcement that Qualcomm was adding UMA support to their dual-mode 3G platform.

Thursday, March 20, 2008

T-Mobile: 10 New UMA Handsets in 08


The recent article about T-Mobile's HotSpot @Home dual-mode service had another interesting fact. T-Mobile marketing vice president David Beigie said that the company will bring 10 new UMA-enabled dual-mode phones to market in 2008.

Today there are 47 handsets for sale right now on the T-Mobile site. Five are already "HotSpot @Home" capable, so this would bring T-Mobile to 15 devices.

By the end of 2008 we can expect about 30% of T-Mobile's portfolio to be UMA enabled.

Not bad.

Tuesday, March 18, 2008

Fido fetches a DMH service with UMA


Information has been leaked about Fido, a mobile brand in for Rogers in Canada, regarding an upcoming dual-mode handset service based on UMA.

According to the post, the service, called UNO, will have two pricing options and feature the sleek Nokia 6301 and the brand new Motorola Z6w. The rumor is of a soft-launch on April 2.

As show, the Nokia 6301 retails for 50 CAD with three year commitment.

For those of you who continue to think "UMA phones are expensive", the 6300, the non-UMA version, is the same price. Eventually the market will realize there's really no premium to Wi-Fi in handsets.

Sagem my429x

Sagem Launches UMA-Based my429x Phone

sagemmy429x

Sagem quiety launched its second UMA-enabled dual-mode handset recently. The my429x is available to subscribers of Orange's unik service that is based on UMA. As Orange continues to drive the dual-mode handset market with its demand, Orange unik subscribers now have more than 12 dual-mode handsets from which to choose.

The Sagem my429x weighs 95 grams and measures 106X46X15 mm. It has the latest multimedia features and joins an ever-growing line-up of other UMA-enabled handsets.

This is Sagem's second UMA-enabled dual-mode handset. Its first, the my419x, recently won a UMA Innovation Award for best dual-mode handset, feature phone

Monday, March 17, 2008

T-Mobile takes 50%

T-Mobile, notoriously quiet about the HotSpot @Home service, is starting to talk about how successful the offer really is.

In an article out today, [Link update: click here] T-Mobile US marketing vice president David Beigie states that nearly half of the subscribers who sign up for the dual-mode handset service are new to T-Mobile. Frankly, that’s a stunning success in the competitive US mobile market.

Orange had originally stated that 15% of Unik subscribers were new to the company. But as the incumbent fixed and mobile provider in France, this makes sense.

As a competitive provider, and the fourth largest provider in the US, T-Mobile is always looking for ways to win new subscribers, and a 50% attraction rate is tremendous.

Wednesday, March 12, 2008

Cinci Bell: Telecom Innovator

There's a good article in Forbes about John Cassidy, CEO of regional fixed/mobile/broadband provider Cincinnati Bell. The article calls Mr. Cassidy "the most honest man in telecom."

It also refers to Cincinnati Bell's dual-mode handset (DMH) service called "Home Run".

In talking about the service, the author makes an interesting comment:

"Wi-Fi will nick Cassidy's traditional businesses, but the technology is too logical to ignore."

I agree that "Wi-Fi is too logical to ignore", and wish more operators considered it the same way. However, Wi-Fi doesn't actually "...nick [Cincinnati Bell's] traditional business..."

An investor pitch from Orange dated December, 2007 (slide 20) highlights how Orange has seentheir dual-mode service actually increase the lifetime value of subscribers who take the service. Rather than 'nicking' the business, Wi-Fi is actually increasing the value of a subscriber to the operator.

Rumor mill: Sony/Ericsson phone close?

Several independent sources have been talking about new UMA-enabled handsets from Sony/Ericsson. There are rumors that the units are in test at different operators. Unfortunately, this typically means they are likely to be 3 to 6 months away from commercial availability.

Sony/Ericsson is the largest handset manufacturer without a UMA device. We can only assume that the pressure from operators offering dual-mode handset services has 'convinced' S/E to jump into the game.

All we can say is "Welcome, the more the merrier!"

Four Out of Five Agree: UMA for Femtocells

Before MWC, I wrote about the incredible amount of UMA-based femtocell news, calling it a ‘femto frenzy’ of activity.

Within the world of femtocells, there are a chosen few committed to the existing 3GPP UMA/GAN standard. All of the other systems/solutions are proprietary. The “UMA-enabled Femtocell” world consists of many key players:

- Solution provider NEC
- Solution provider Motorola
- Femtocell provider Ubiquisys
- Femtocell provider Motorola
- Femtocell provider Netgear

So, let’s count the number of announced operator femtocell trials and see where UMA is involved:

1. During MWC, pan-European mobile operator O2 announced they were conducting a femtocell trial with NEC.

2. Also during MWC, Scandinavian provider Telia announced a femtocell trial based with Motorola.

3. Then just this week, an article from Fierce Wireless editor Brian Dolan suggests that T-Mobile International will be trialing Ubiquisys femtocells with NEC.

4. Softbank in Japan has announced trials with nearly every supplier on the market, including Ubiquisys, NEC and Motorola.

5. The only other announced trial I’m aware of is Vodafone Group’s announcement to trial Alcatel/Lucent and Huawei, clearly not a UMA-based trial.

Unless I’m mistaken (which I’m sure you’ll to tell me if I am):

Four out of five femtocell trials include a UMA-based system.

This reminds me of the old Trident gum ad where “four out of five dentists agree…”

I attribute this to a couple of reasons:

- It works. Novel but true. UMA has been commercially deployed for more than two years.

- Operators actually want a standard interface. As much as Alcatel/Lucent, Huawei, and even Nokia/Siemens are trying to push their own proprietary approaches, the operators have had enough. They want an open, public standard interface for femtocells.

- UMA does more than one thing. After deploying a femtocell service, a mobile operator may want to add a fixed line VoIP service (like T-Mobile US). The same UMA infrastructure supports that, or dual-mode phones, or softmobiles.

Next, let's see if we can get to 9 out of ten...

[UPDATE MARCH 20] Good posted on ThinkFemto about a similar topic. I have a bit more detail. For some reason, ThinkFemto decided to throw in a bunch of picocell wins that ip.Access got, but they aren't femtocells.


Monday, March 10, 2008

Apple vs Blackberry in the enterprise? RIM has the edge.


Last week Apple made noise about opening the iPhone up to developers to support more enterprise oriented applications.

UMA’s standard position on applications is “If they work over GSM, they’ll work better/faster/cheaper over Wi-Fi and UMA!” It’s a good (and easy) position to be in.

Given UMA technology is basically agnostic to applications running above it (even SIP), why would UMA Today weigh in on an enterprise applications battle between the Blackberry and Apple?

Frankly, it’s because UMA gives RIM an edge.

Let me explain.

These heavy duty devices are always struggling with power usage. One of the banes of ‘smart phones’ with big screens and lots of features is battery performance, and it’s here, deep inside these enterprise devices, that UMA gives RIM the edge.

Consider how UMA works:

When a UMA-enabled device moves within range of Wi-Fi, the handset establishes a direct IP tunnel to the mobile core network using the Wi-Fi radio. Once in place, all mobile services (voice, SMS, MMS, …) are tunneled to the phone over IP. Because the GSM/3G radio is no longer used, it is put into a hibernation mode. In effect, only one RAN radio is powered on concurrently with UMA. That’s pretty efficient.

Compare this with how an iPhone, or any non-UMA dual-mode phone (think Nokia E and N) works. When the iPhone moves into Wi-Fi coverage, the Wi-Fi radio powers on. But there is no connection from the Wi-Fi radio to the mobile core network. Therefore, for users to receive cellular services (ie 'a phone call'), the GSM radio must remain on, concurrently with the Wi-Fi radio.

That sucking sound you hear is the battery on the iPhone draining…

That’s not fair, it’s not specific to iPhones, it’s the same with any dual-mode E or N series from Nokia that doesn’t have UMA.

This is a fundament advantage over any non-UMA dual-mode handset. Any time you see or hear someone complaining about ‘Wi-Fi battery life’, you can be sure they are talking about a non-UMA device.

Thursday, March 06, 2008

Ono!?! Definitely Oh Yes!

Spanish quad-play operator Ono is the latest to launch a dual-mode handset service based on UMA technology. Ono’s service, called “io”, offers consumers the same rate on calls to fixed and mobile lines 24 hours a day.

From Wi-Fi, it is a rate of 0.0€/minute on calls to other Ono mobile or fixed lines, and just 0.11€/minute on calls to other Spanish operators.

Outside the home, it is still 0.0€/minute on calls to other Ono mobile or fixed lines, and a flat rate of 0.15€/minute on calls to fixed and mobile lines in Spain.

Currently Ono offers Samsung and Nokia products, with more phones in the works.

Ono is a quad-play competitive provider in Spain, offering mobile, fixed, broadband and television services.

Monday, March 03, 2008

VCC?!?! Still??? Really???

VCC, or voice call continuity, seems to still be hanging around in parts of the industry. I must say I continue to be shocked that anyone would even consider it.

First, it must be getting close to done, but for some baffling reason is not completed yet. I think VCC started back in 2005, the same as UMA. If you recall, UMA was actually ratified by the 3GPP in April 2005 (2G) and has since added 3G support, all in the same timeframe that VCC is still languishing.

My position has been and continues to be that VCC is for fixed operators. They have SIP core switches (a VCC requirement) and no direct connection to the mobile service core. I think dual-mode service for fixed operators is a tough sell for many reasons far beyond technology.

Of course, UMA is a 3GPP technology, therefore CDMA networks don’t have an equivalent approach. Some have suggested that these operators may opt for a dual-mode handset/VCC offer, but I think mobile operators in general are too smart to fall for the vendor community’s push on VCC.

VCC offers a different set of services to subscribers when on Wi-Fi than what’s available on the macro network. This is because the handset connects to the SIP core when on Wi-Fi, and to the MSC when on cellular. Different core networks support different services. It’s inconceivable to me that any mobile operator would attempt to roll out a service which didn’t work the same across the entire network.

Frankly the CDMA operators are simply going to do femtocells for their ‘home zone’ service offers. Witness Sprint and Airave. They must have a response to Wi-Fi-based home zone offers like T-Mobile’s HotSpot @Home, and femtocells are a viable alternative.

UMA is the only viable technology for dual-mode services. Period.

GAN Iu-Mode Stage 3 Complete

At the 3GPP meeting two weeks ago, the GAN/UMA working group ratified the Stage 3 requirements for Iu-mode support. It's done. Now... how to get the femtocell community to use an existing standard rather than creating something new from scratch...

Friday, February 29, 2008

TelecomTV Gets UMA/GAN

In a rather odd bit of coverage, TelecomTV today posted a piece on UMA/GAN. Remarkably, the post correctly positioned the technology as supportive of both ‘that dual-mode thing’ as well as femtocells.

Now that’s a refreshing surprise. I must say I’m getting sick and tired of the ‘UMA vs Femtocell’ articles. I thought by now everyone knew that UMA is the leading technology powering femtocells. If we need a comparison, let is be ‘Wi-Fi versus femtocells’.

To that end, I think the video interview TelecomTV did on Wi-Fi versus Femtocell was more interesting (in the clip titled ‘broadband down the toilet’, at the 2 min mark).

Anyhow, I suspect the piece came from the announcement that Iu mode was finalized in the GAN working group. But after reading the piece, I think the goal was point out that consumers don’t buy technology or acronyms. Okay then.

Friday, February 22, 2008

T-Mobile Goes VoIP!!!

In one of the worse kept secrets in the UMA industry, on Thursday T-Mobile US announced a new “Talk Forever” fixed line home phone service. The service uses the existing UMA network infrastructure to provide fixed line VoIP service in the home.

The application is similar to Vonage, where subscribers port their fixed-line number to a new provider (previously Vonage or now T-Mobile). The subscriber gets a terminal adaptor for the home. The terminal adaptor is used to connect to the existing fixed line/cordless phone in the home and route calls over IP and broadband.

For T-Mobile, this is an extremely low cost way to drive more fixed-mobile substitution (FMS). For a variety of reasons, there continues to be consumer preference for fixed line phones in the home. A mobile-only operator would typically be locked out of providing fixed line services. Now with the flexibility and investment protection of UMA, T-Mobile is able to extend their existing mobile core network to provide fixed line VoIP.

Certainly for Vonage, this is a bit concerning. Unlimited calling plans from Vonage are $25/month. T-Mobile is dramatically undercutting the market with a $10 offer. And just recently I signed up for a flat rate fixed line service from ATT for $40/month. Even Comcast, the ‘leader’ in fixed line VoIP in the US is offering an introductory rate of $29.99/month (normally $39.99).

As pointed out in several articles, T-Mobile now offers a LOT of calling for very little money. With a $40/month mobile plan (which offers 1,000 mobile minutes, plus unlimited nights/weekends), it is possible to add unlimited mobile calling from Wi-Fi (home, office, international) for $10 (HotSpot @Home). Or for $10 add unlimited fixed line calling from home. Or bundle it all together for $60 and get more calling than one person could ever use! Is this why AT&T and Verizon Wireless launched ‘unlimited’ mobile calling plans?

PS – the service uses the Linksys WRTU54G gateway/router.

PPS – will they add a UMA-based soft mobile client as well?

Congratulations T-Mobile.

Wednesday, February 20, 2008

3G 'dual-mode' phones are on the way

As the dual-mode handset (DMH) market continues its explosive growth, the focus for devices in 2008 has started to shift. With nearly 20 UMA-based dual mode 2G phones, there’s now solid demand for UMA-based 3G devices.

One of the most exciting announcements at the Mobile World Congress this year was platform support for UMA-enabled 3G/2G/Wi-Fi handsets. I guess we can’t call them ‘dual-mode’, perhaps we’re going to have to move to ‘multi-mode’ devices.

There were two 3G platform announcements:

First, NXP, a long-time supporter of UMA-enabled platforms announced support for a 3G/UMTS version of their Nexperia product line. NXP is supplier to UMA-device powerhouse Samsung, so look for 3G handsets from them in the future.

Second was an announcement that Qualcomm and Kineto have developed a UMA-enabled version of their 72xx series platform. Qualcomm’s market position makes this a very strategic announcement, opening up the potential for UMA-enabled devices from many different handset manufacturers.

This is a 'rolls down hill' type of business. Operators decide what they need. They put pressure on their handset suppliers. The handset suppliers turn to their platform suppliers to get platforms to meet those requirements. The platform suppliers work with the component providers to develop sub-systems to meet the need.

It's clear that demand from the top continues to be strong for UMA-enabled handsets.


Tuesday, February 19, 2008

UMA-based Femtos on Trial

One of the big news items of this year’s Mobile World Congress (MWC) was femtocells. As reported here, there was a ‘femto frenzy’ building in the market. Then on Monday, two UMA-based femtocell trial announcements hit the wire.

The first was O2, announcing they are trialing a femtocell system from NEC. This was on the heels of NEC announcing their femtocell solution.

Second Telia announced plans for a femtocell trial to complement their Home Free dual-mode handset service. I recommend clicking through on the link, it’s an excellent way to work on your Swedish. Telia has been very aggressive in rolling out Home Free across Telia properties and has used a UMA-based solution from Motorola for some time.

I think UMA is starting to have an effect on the femtocell market. Clearly operators see the advantages (fastest time to market, fastest time to standards, robust, proven, investment protection for new FMC applications) and I’m certain there will be more UMA-based femtocell announcements to come.

Motorola #2

The rumored Motorola ‘Marco’ handset has come to life! Now known as the Z6w, this is the second UMA-enabled Motorola handset. No word yet on which operator will be the first to put it into commercial deployment, but T-Mobile is a good guess.

This is a welcome development for UMA. Motorola has been languishing in the dual-mode/UMA market and this is a stylish offering. With any luck, there's more where this came from.

UMA Innovation Awards

One of the highlights of the Mobile World Congress was the UMA Today Innovation Awards. The response from the operator and vendor community was stronger than expected and really put the pressure on the judges to sort out the winners.

The program was sponsored by Orange and UMA Today. Orange further agreed to host the presentation ceremony on their stand at the MWC. Done with typical French flair, Orange made the event a classy affair with champagne, hors d’oeuvres (or was it cava and tapas?) and great hospitality.

Awards were presented to leaders in the UMA market. In the end, Orange was honored as “Most Influential Company”, and I can assure you it wasn’t simply because of the champagne!

Congratulations to all the winners. And for those who didn’t win or didn’t enter, don’t worry, there’s always the 2009 program.

Saturday, February 09, 2008

Acme joins the UMA team

A trend in the industry is to integrate higher level security capabilities (VPN tunnels) into network interface points such as Session Boarder Controllers (SBCs). Picking up on this trend is Acme Packet who announced earlier this week a new line-up of products to meet the security needs of a UMA-enabled network. The products blend Acme's traditional SBC with the functionality of a UMA security gateway (SeGW).

Unfortunately, due to the late announcement, we weren’t able to get them on the list of UMA companies at MWC, but stop by to see them in Hall 4.

Friday, February 08, 2008

Femto's frenzy

In the drive up to Mobile World Congress, there has been ‘femto frenzy’ of press releases. A large chunk of the news has been from UMA-based femtocell players.

Sensing an opportunity to play a significant roll in the market, UMA-based femtocell manufacturers have been aggressive about making the case for UMA as the ‘most viable’ path to standardization of a RAN Gateway/ ‘Iu-over-IP’ architecture.

There are rumors that there may be some operator announcements at MWC regarding UMA-based femtocell trial activities. We’ll be sure to update the site as the news comes in.

  1. NEC and Kineto propose approach for rapid femtocell standardization
  2. Motorola announces a family of femtocell solutions
  3. NEC and NETGEAR team to develop an integrated 3G access point for femtocell solution
  4. Kineto ready to support commercial femtocell rollouts
  5. NETGEAR and Kineto to showcase 3G femto home access solution at MWC
  6. NEC announces trial of femtocell solution with mobile operators
  7. Kineto and Ubiquisys announce successful interoperability testing between Zonegate and UNC
  8. Femto Forum steps up drive for harmonized network integration

As one insider told me that only "...relentless evidence of practical deployments and practical challenges overcome" will convince the market that UMA is the most viable technology for a femtocell /network integration standard. This looks like the start of some relentless-ness.

Wednesday, February 06, 2008

Fusion fizzles

[UPDATE] As they say, the rumors of Fusion's demise were exaggerated, prompting a story titled "BT Forced to Defend Fusion" from Total Telcoms. I do believe that BT has some challenges related to Fusion, but I'm glad BT continues to work through them.


Two years ago I wrote a post called “Why Fusion hasn’t fused”.

Here we are, two years on, and it looks like BT is coming to a similar conclusion. As reported in the Daily Mail, BT will stop marketing Fusion to consumers.

Many will want to jump to the conclusion that this signals the demise of dual-mode handset (DMH) services in general. Absolutely not, DMH is on fire and continues to expand. I happen to think that this action simply confirms what we’ve all known, that DMH services which focus on the fixed network are doomed from the start.

Let me explain.

Fundamentally DMH is about fixed-to-mobile substitution (FMS). But as a fixed operator, what you really want is MFS, or to pull minutes *off* the mobile network and on to the fixed network. It's fighting the tide.

In the case of BT, any voice minute that moved onto the mobile network cost them more because it was carried through their Vodafone MVNO rather than their own discounted fixed line network.

The value proposition and the service objectives of DMH are completely mis-aligned for fixed operators. Another reason why VCC, primarily for fixed operators, will never get off the ground.

After that, there are several reasons why fixed operators in general will always have a very tough time with DMH:

- No retail presence. Who buys a phone today without first picking it up and touching it (I guess about 45,000 people in the UK!). Last year I think BT did develop a retail push with a UK outfit, but if you're not 'retail savvy' already, the mobile market is extremely competitive place to learn.

- Because they have 0% mobile market share, none of the handset manufacturers would do any custom/special work for them. Again a problem for all fixed operators (I'm thinking cable companies now, not so much a problem for an integrated operator like AT&T). Therefore, they never got leading edge handsets. Orange can push Nokia or Samsung to develop DMH product, but BT, no way.

- BT is not considered a 'mobile' company. But DMH is a mobile phone service. So they had a giant market perception problem to work through, trying to convince consumers that given the choice of getting mobile service from Vodafone, T-Mobile, Orange, O2 and BT, that good 'ole BT was the right choice. This is going against the grain of years of existing market perception, it's a billion $$ public relations campaign, not a couple of bill inserts and some print advertising.

I think these are all the same reasons why DT's T-One flopped. I think this is why we don't hear a word about Embarq's service in the US.

Notice none of the problems are attributed to technology. I think we all know UMA works.

I think any DMH service which caters to the fixed side of the house is doomed from the start. This is about FMS.

Unfortunate, but not surprising.

Thursday, January 24, 2008

Samsung stays on a roll with the new P220

This week Orange began selling Samsung’s latest UMA-enabled handset, the P220. This sleek candy-bar model is the seventh model from Samsung. All the models are based on NXP’s highly optimized UMA/Wi-Fi platform which delivers stellar Wi-Fi performance (battery, range).

Samsung continues to roll as the leading supplier of UMA-enabled devices. At last check, 25% of the Samsung models for sale on the Orange/France website were UMA-enabled.

Thursday, January 03, 2008

Orange Hits 9 with UMA-enabled Pearl


Quietly over the holiday break, Orange added the UMA-enabled RIM Pearl (8120) to its line-up of UMA-enabled handsets.

This brings Orange to 9 devices available for the Unik service. With devices from Samsung, Nokia, LG, Sagem and RIM, Orange continues to push handset manufacturers to support Wi-Fi and UMA technology.

2008 will bring a flood of new devices with an eye towards 3G-based Wi-Fi-enabled handsets with UMA.

FMC Services Top Light Reading List


In wrapping up the year’s top 10 operator service stories from 2007, Light Reading named an unprecedented two (out of ten) UMA-based services to the list. Congratulations to Orange (#7) and T-Mobile (#4) for their noteworthy and visionary dual-mode service offers.

Look for more innovations in 2008:


7. At FT, FMC spells UNIK
It's our first entry for France Telecom SA (NYSE: FTE - message board), which has taken a very Gallic approach to fixed/mobile convergence (FMC) by giving its service a name that sounds great in French but plain weird elsewhere.

That service is UNIK (or YOUNEEK, if you live in Paris). And it's a winner for le grand porteur's domestic business, Orange France (Paris: OGE - message board).

In June we reported: "Orange France has left other European operators in the dust when it comes to fixed/mobile convergence." (See Orange Doubles FMC Customers.)

Those others include some pretty big names, too. (See Deutsche Telekom Cancels FMC Service and BT's Flat Fusion .)

The service has proved popular in France because it has been well marketed and, er, it works. It even got a namecheck from FT's CEO when the carrier reported a leap in profits for the first half of 2007. (See Emerging Growth Pumps Up FT.)

With solid growth continuing towards the end of the year -- 468,000 dualmode WiFi/GSM handsets sold for its unlicensed mobile access (UMA)-based service by the end of September -- the carrier is now planning a 3G version of the service. (See Orange Builds on FMC Base and Unik 3G.)

http://www.lightreading.com/document.asp?doc_id=141946


4. Born in the UMA
OK, so we've already had one FMC entry, but we make the rules, and we've stuck another one in.

This time it's T-Mobile USA 's HotSpot @Home service, launched in June this year. (See T-Mobile Launches UMA in USA.)

What's really special about this service is that subscribers not only get to hook up to their WiFi connections at home for cheap calls, but they can make mobile calls through any of the operator's 8,500 hotspots around the U.S. for just $10 a month.

http://www.lightreading.com/document.asp?doc_id=141946&page_number=2